Stardew Valley Rancher or Tiller

In Stardew Valley, establishing your farm is your primary objective, and you should strive to do this in the most efficient manner possible. Just like in real life, your farm may be focused on crops, animals, or a combination of the two, and the game does present you with two choices at level 5 that will help you maximise your farm based on your preferred play style and farming methods. Consequently, which of these two possibilities, Rancher and Tiller, Crop-based or Animal-based, would I consider to be the superior choice?

Tiller is the greatest profession since it increases the value of your crops by 10%. However, at level 10, you may unlock the Artisan talent, which increases the value of all Artisan items by 40%, making them the best career. Tiller gives you a great deal of security from the beginning to the end of the game, while Rancher lacks these excellent characteristics and is dependent on animals.

Stardew Valley is a game that is strongly dependant on you making a number of excellent choices if you don’t want to end up having to spend a bunch of money later on to correct a mistake you made while playing. So, consequently, before making any of these choices, you should first comprehend precisely what you are getting yourself into in the long term, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of the decision and its implications.

To be quite honest, a lot of players are torn between choosing between the Rancher and the Tiller professions. Some players love the constancy of the Rancher profession, while others want to store up or transform their crops into Artisan items and sell them for a large profit.

Despite the fact that the proper decision may seem to be obvious, if you want your farm to be animal-based and if you love to raise animals, you should choose Rancher as your profession. While if you wish to cultivate crops, you should choose Tiller, which seems to be a straightforward choice, but is everything but.

In order to assist you in your decision-making, I have broken down each profession for you, providing you with its advantages and disadvantages and leaving you with a definitive response at the end that will be very helpful to you in the future.

Rancher Profession

Stardew Valley Rancher or Tiller

If you pick the Rancher profession at level 5, you will immediately see a 20 percent rise in the price of your animal goods, which is a fairly excellent deal in my opinion. Obviously, the 40 percent price rise for Artisan items is significantly superior, but players cannot ignore the fact that the 20 percent price boost for Rancher goods is also a significant bonus in and of its own. Not only that, but you’ll also have to make a selection between two specialities at the level of 10.


The Coopmaster speciality makes your coop animals more sociable, reduces the time it takes to incubate eggs by half, and improves the overall quality of all of your coop animal goods by increasing their quality. As a result, this buff is applicable to all coop animals, including chickens, ducks, rabbits, void chickens, and dinosaurs, among other things.


The Shepherd speciality makes your barn animals more sociable, boosts the capacity of sheep to produce wool more quickly, and improves the overall quality of barn animal goods, among other benefits. This buff is applicable to all barnyard animals, including cows, goats, sheep, and pigs, among others.

If I had to choose between the Coopmaster and the Shepherd, I’d say the Shepherd has more to offer in terms of skills and abilities. When sold, they fetch a higher price in gold, and the items they produce are more valuable than those produced by the coop animals. Overall, I’d recommend selecting the most appropriate choice depending on the extent of availability of that option on your map.


You get a lot of Animal products by becoming a rancher.

Your Animals products can be sold for 20% more than their actual price.


It can be time-consuming to watch over the Animals.

The cost of taking care of the animals can be a little bit high.

Tiller Profession

Choosing the Tiller profession at level 5 immediately results in a 10 percent rise in the value of your crops in the game world. The fact that your property already produces a large number of crops, along with a ten percent rise in the price of each product, makes this a decent enough buff on its own.

So, if you previously sold 10 tomatoes for 100g, you will now be able to sell them for 110 gold, which may not seem like much, but it is still beneficial until reaching level 10.

At level 10, you must choose between two specialisations: astronomy and physics.


Stardew Valley Rancher or Tiller

Because of the Artisan specialty, all of your Artisan items are valued 40 percent more than they would otherwise be. Produced on your farm using a variety of Artisan Equipments, artisan goods are objects that may be sold or given away as gifts. The majority of the time, they can be completely processed within a few hours or days in-game.

When the star quality of the artisan items isn’t important, some artisans overlook the star quality of the raw materials that were utilised to manufacture them. The lone exception to this rule is the Ostrich Egg, since the star quality of its Artisan product will always equal the star quality of the item that was utilised in its production.

Despite the fact that the price of all artisanal products has increased by 40%, staples such as oil and coffee have not benefited from this rise. Other things that have a similar religious belief include the Tree Syrups, which are comprised of Maple Syrup, Oak Resin, and Pine Tar, among others. However, despite the fact that they are classified as Artisan items, they do not reap the benefits of the Artisan vocation.


It is possible to cultivate your crops 10 percent quicker if you specialise in Agriculturist. This boost is disproportionately benefited by the Tiller perk, since if your crops grow more quickly, you may sell more of them for a 10 percent price rise in a relatively short period of time.

In case you’re wondering, there are tactics to apply while picking between the Tiller and the Rancher, as shown below. The first is as simple as choosing the Tiller and progressing through the levels until you reach level 10, at which point you may choose the Artisan specialty. Once you’ve obtained it, you may begin transforming all of your items and animals into Artisan-quality merchandise.

Because transforming your animal products into artisan items like as mayonnaise or cheese increases their value by 40%, it is one of the most popular justifications for choosing the Tiller over the Rancher. The second method is to choose the Rancher profession, which allows you to collect and store all of your Artisan items at the same time.

Once you have accumulated enough Artisan goods, you may spend 10,000g to change your profession at a later time. However, I do not recommend this technique until you have amassed a significant number of Artisan goods.


The Artisan buff at level 10 is really good.

You can get more out of both your crops and your animals.

You generally don’t have to spend too much time watching over your crops on the farm.


Stardew Valley Rancher or Tiller

The Artisan profession forces you to change your play style.

It is usually not the easiest profession to take, especially if you take the Artisan specialization because you are going to spend a lot of time gathering Artisan goods.

Which Profession Is Better: Rancher or Tiller?

When comparing and contrasting both features with one another, there are some quite distinct differences between them. You have to make a decision depending on how you want your farm to appear in the late stages of the match. I also included methods on how to get the most of both the Tiller and Rancher professions, so if you think the playstyle is a good fit for you, you may give it a go.

At level 10, players are more likely to earn more if they choose the Tiller over the Rancher; nevertheless, this does not imply that choosing Rancher is a terrible decision in every case. Naturally, if you prefer to care for animals rather than crops due to the fact that it is simpler for you, then choosing the Rancher makes a lot of sense, particularly if you do not intend to produce much or any Artisan items in the future.

On top of that, the animal product bonus has been doubled from 10 percent to 20 percent in patch 1.1, which means that there will likely be a significant rise in the number of Ranchers in Stardew Valley as a result of this.

Bryan V. Root
Bryan V. Root
Articles: 460

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *